Nov 102006

I had intended to continue on the subject of the dangers of certain forms of secularism this week, particularly since it generated a stream of comments, some of which appeared to miss the point of the article entirely. But as I sit at my desk my thoughts seem occupied with a different topic altogether.

Whatever I do these days, I seem unable to shake off the scenes of the women confronting the Israeli army unarmed in the occupied Palestinian town of Beit Hanoun. I do not know what it is about them that intrigues me so much, and keeps their images engraved in my memory. Perhaps it is the thought of women defying the soldiers of the fourth largest army in the world unarmed, perhaps it is the fascinating collective power these women exuded, or the poignant imbalance of their situation. Although the soldiers had the upper hand in material terms, with their sophisticated armour and deadly weaponry, it was the women who won the moral case.

We have grown used to reading of the plight of the wretched Muslim woman living in societies that crush their will, trample over their rights and strip them of their freedom. Every day new voices join themselves to the endless lament, pleading with the West to intervene and liberate Islam’s “caged virgins”. But on the woman crushed beneath tanks in Baghdad, dying at checkpoints in Qalandia, or buried beneath the rubble of a shelter in Qana, these voices remain silent. The woman gunned down by a soldier is of no interest to them, if she happens to find herself in Palestine, Iraq, or Lebanon. She simply is not relevant to the “liberation agenda”.

Perhaps the women of Jenin, Falluja, or Tyre are not photogenic enough for them. Their photos will never adorn the front pages of newspapers and magazines, unlike the girls of the much applauded “cedar revolution” with their tight designer jeans, sunglasses, and expensive hairdos. It was interesting to hear journalists report on the Beit Hanoun protest where two women were murdered in cold blood and many more injured. With all the talk of “robes”, “abayas” and “scarves” one would have thought the reporters were commenting on a fashion show, as though these women had defied the Israeli curfew for the sole purpose of exhibiting their costumes. With all the emphasis on the women’s dress the reporters stressed their difference, dehumanizing them, obscuring their womanhood, reducing them to a piece of cloth. It was as though what these women wore lent a measure of justification to the soldiers’ crimes against them.

“Don’t be a victim if in your reflection we do not see ourselves, but a distant, strange world, we neither understand, nor wish to understand”.

The women liberation warriors are dumbstruck when the oppressor is not the classical culprit: the tyrant of One Thousand and One Nights and old Arab tales, but a whole occupation army with its soldiers, guns, tanks and warplanes. Two cases before us divest the discourse of Muslim women’s emancipation of any credibility. The first is that of my friend, the Turkish MP Merve Kavakci, a university lecturer who was elected to the Turkish parliament in April 18th 1999. On May 2nd when she entered parliament for the oath-taking ceremony, she walked into a storm, facing the taunts of hundreds of men demanding her expulsion. Not only was Kavakci expelled from parliament, she was stripped of her Turkish citizenship, all because she chose to wear a headscarf. She is one of thousands of women: university graduates, doctors, engineers and teachers denied their civil and political rights for simply choosing a type of dress which their governments disapprove of.

The other is Jameela al-Shanti, elected member of the Palestinian Legislative Council, who related her poignant story in the Guardian yesterday, giving us a small glimpse of the tragedy of living under occupation as a woman. Her home was bombed, many of her friends and relatives killed and injured, but as she herself put it, “I have yet to hear western condemnation that I, an elected MP, have had my home demolished and relatives killed by Israel’s bombs. When the bodies of my friends and colleagues were torn apart there was not one word from those who claim to be defenders of women’s rights on Capitol Hill and in 10 Downing Street”.

Kavakci and al-Shanti’s fault is twofold. They fit neither the much-cherished stereotype of the oppressed Muslim woman, Taliban style, nor the western model conceived as the sole path to women’s liberation. They form part of a simply non-existing category. For if you are a Muslim woman, you can either be the victim of a suffocating oppressive patriarchal society which dictates everything you do, including what you should wear and whom you should marry, or a woman who has turned her back on all that is “Islamic”. If you are the former, then await our benevolent intervention to free you of your bondage and break your chains and shackles. If the latter, expect to be celebrated and to have your photos decorate glossy magazines from London to Paris, Amsterdam to Washington, Hirsi style. You are saying what we need said, fighting our battles for us, without risking the charge of Islamophobia and racism. You are the liberated one worthy of liberating her co-religionists.

What is ironic is that vast numbers of Muslim women today fit neither of these categories. Visit any university in Cairo, Kuala Lampur, Damascus, or Jakarta and you will see the Islamic head cover everywhere, even in states that ban the practice with the text of the law and the force of the police, like Turkey and Tunisia. These very same institutions had until recently stood on the vanguard of the production of the Western feminist model.

My own mother attended one of these universities in the early 1970s. She wore neither my scarf, nor my long skirts. Her mother before her was barely literate and hardly crossed the doors of her home. Today, both my mother and I have moved away from the category of my grandmother and the Parisian woman all educated Arab females aspired to emulate through much of the 20th century. The category which would accommodate us, but remains missing, would have to be complex, neither traditionally Islamic, nor modernised along western lines. In its complexity, it would reflect the multiple forms of modernity and Islamicity at once.

The roads to modernisation, Islamisation, and liberation are not one but many. The world is vaster than London and Paris.

When faced with the rhetoric of Muslim women’s emancipation we would do well to scratch beneath its outer crust in search of what lies underneath. The liberation of Muslim women, just like the democratisation and reform of the “wider Middle East”, is often used as a vehicle of justification and legitimisation of unjustifiable and illegitimate interests and interventions. Muslim women, just like their sisters in the third world, in Africa, or Asia, suffer from manifold problems, under-educated, impoverished, under-represented, and discriminated against. But they can be sure that neither Blair, Bush, nor their many mouthpieces are losing any sleep over their hard lot, or over the tragedies of their sisters in Palestine, Iraq, Afghanistan, or Lebanon.

The burden of liberation rests on the shoulders of the Muslim woman herself. It is she who must define her own direction and chart her own destiny, not those who cry crocodile tears over her.


First Published in The Guardian, Friday 10 November 2006

Warning: count(): Parameter must be an array or an object that implements Countable in /home/soumayag/public_html/wp-includes/class-wp-comment-query.php on line 399

  59 Responses to “The banished voices of Muslim women”

  1. Hey there! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow you if that would be
    okay. I’m definitely enjoying your blog and look forward to new posts.

  2. You made some good points there. I did a search on the subject matter and found most guys will approve with your website.

  3. i need pink hoverboard at this time there hence perfectly ,and even vogue plus super adorable! just can’t wait around to have our minute pair!

  4. This is my first time pay a visit at here and i am actually pleassant to read all at alone place.|

  5. The next step is to use items that minimize acne you lessens the chances of potential outbreaks and might currently have.

    My web page :: best acne spot treatment drugstore

  6. Not pleased together with your existing webhosting and area title supplier why not switch over to us,
    simply contact our technical assist group who will probably be glad to help you.

    my web blog :: web hosting jsp support (Tamika)

  7. I always emailed this weblog post page to all my associates, for the reason that if like to read it afterward my contacts will too.

    Check out my webpage … How to get a real estate license in GA (Angelia)

  8. Additionally, you might discover you have rather more success with
    selling jewellery-making provides on eBay than with promoting your finished handcrafted jewellery!

    Here is my web site heart charm bracelet sterling silver;

  9. My site was down last two days throughout weekend.

    Also visit my blog – web hosting experience (Miriam)

  10. Use this setting because it fits you.

    Here is my blog … silver bead charms

  11. You need to confirm that all of the information that’s saved
    on the internet host’s servers is sufficiently
    backed up. This is particularly vital if you are working an online enterprise, and
    have to retailer customer info on databases positioned on the net

    my blog … web hosting vs dns hosting

  12. Yet one more technique to convert conventional earrings is to go magnetic.

    Also visit my homepage hearts bracelet (Julius)

  13. An SSL certificates can be purchased from most internet
    hosting providers. Displaying it on your ecommerce site verifies that your website transactions are protected and

    Also visit my weblog: tsohost outgoing mail server (Jeana)

  14. Open supply commerce is an internet store management software
    program program.

    Also visit my web-site – tsohost billing

  15. You now not have the necessity to have separate servers for Windows and Linux based
    mostly hosting.

    Check out my page; web hosting comparison chart (Jody)

  16. These backups can be found for restoral upon request.

    my weblog web hosting kolkata, Alexandra,

  17. Both are wonderful and absolutely featured for constructing and publishing web sites.

    (Uploading a web site to the web is called publishing”).

    Check out my page; fasthosts

  18. And who better to seduce us along with her charms than the lady who performed Demelza, the young
    servant maid who seduced Ross Poldark and won his

    Visit my site: angel wings chain

  19. You may flaunt their Kasu jewelry collection on traditional in addition to fashionable outfits
    with equal elegance.

    Also visit my webpage – double necklace (Shirley)

  20. Skilled Net designers must also guarantee WEBSITE POSITIONING optimization of your web site and forestall it
    from turn out to be inaccessible and unusable.

    Check out my weblog: tsohost change nameservers (Moises)

  21. Students from University Tunku Abdul Rahman(UTAR), Malaysia are operating a PR Campaign for 2015-sixteen: Volunteerism Vs Expertise Escapism with
    the focus on smartphone dependency, which hopes to encourage the audience to cut back their level of dependency on their smartphones and construct
    a positive and interactive relationship with out the usage of expertise.
    Moodoff Day is supporting the UTAR PR campaign.

    My web blog – web hosting portland oregon

  22. Likelihood is you’ll be quite pleased with what you find on the market.

    my weblog; web hosting exchange email (

  23. Effectively, there’s a few designers which might be sure to be classic collectibles just a few many years from now.

    my weblog – ring charm

  24. One other consideration is the uptime guarantee.
    You may need to make sure that in case your web site is down for quite a lot of
    minutes a month you’ll be getting a refund out of your internet hosting company.
    The gold customary for uptime ensures is 99.9% per thirty days.

    my blog: tsohost lite hosting; Derek,

  25. I’ve been with tsohost (earlier Zesthost) since 2005 and might nonetheless advocate them to everybody
    who needs a great and skilled hosting provider with a wonderful help team….
    all the time out there and providing good and fast options!!

    Look at my blog :: uk2 infra shared web hosting (Heriberto)

  26. Companies lease the space for the website on the cloud.

    Feel free to surf to my web site: web hosting godaddy review – Leila,

  27. Tying knots generally is a bit difficult. I found
    this very useful website that has a listing of
    fifty knots and the way to tie them This website is nice as a result of it has a step by
    step approach so that anybody can use the knowledge and come out with actual duplications after the first strive.
    The diagrams are animated which exhibits how you can transfer the ends of the material to be
    knotted and this is a higher studying software than a one dimensional diagram.

    Here is my web site – gold jewellery long chains (Janice)

  28. Finally, you have management over the overall outlook of your web

    Also visit my website – web hosting dallas (Ira)

  29. Folks have been going crazy over the Lungi dance and
    actually going 1..2..3..four whereas getting on the dance flooring.
    However what’s currently trending on the style scene is Deepika
    and her styling.

    my blog: joma jewellery a little wish (Shelby)

  30. Internet hosting prices is perhaps tremendously lower in nations like India
    as compared to the western international locations so your internet hosting service might be provided at an incredibly low price.

    However, the heavy most people don’t have any want for dedicated hosting, plus it costs $99 per 30 days.
    A great website helps the master announce the deserves and advantages of his products and services in direction of the multitude of individuals
    together with producing site visitors on the website to generate an extra revenue.
    The eventual goal in the cloud is to supply simple scalable use of computing sources and IT Companies.
    Internet servers can current a thousand’s of Web sites
    per server.

    Have a look at my site: web hosting hostgator (Randy)

  31. Jaipur Kundan Meena Jadau is certainly one of its varieties
    in the world. Fantastically enameled artistic
    gold jewelry studded with flat diamonds and colored gemstones are acknowledged as an indication of aristocracy since Mogul interval.
    Gem and Jewellery industry of Jaipur offers dream jobs
    to many.

    Here is my web page :: silver plated bangles

  32. Generally a particular width will be required if a large diamond is
    set in the ring, with a purpose to accommodate the width and depth of the
    diamond within the band.

    My weblog: bracelet macrame

  33. When photographing a jewelry piece to sell on-line, aim
    to current it attractively, in a well-lit, close-up and clear

    Look into my page – rose gold gold (Ollie)

  34. An entertaining hub full of helpful advice and suggestions!

    Visit my homepage :: tsohost whm; Chau,

  35. Intuit: Intuit gives some very simple web design providers.

    Mainly, you pick a design, customise it, and publish it.
    There are many templates to choose from, you’ll be able to register your own domain identify as you set every little thing else up, you may
    rest assured that there will likely be assist for you should you want it, and you may make sure that the instruments are
    as foolproof as physically possible. This is one
    of the final no fuss no muss selections, and is a great choice especially i you
    don’t take into account your self to be significantly internet savvy.

    My homepage :: web hosting wix

  36. Buying costume jewelery for on a regular basis wear is a superb different to wearing your expensive jewelery
    out daily. Many costume items are beautiful and really properly

    My blog post … necklace coin (Henry)

  37. Thanks for your marvelous posting! I quite enjoyed reading it, you
    may be a great author.I will make certain to bookmark your blog and may
    come back from now on. I want to encourage you to continue your great writing, have a nice holiday weekend!

    Feel free to visit my web page: Supplement Journal – Maximus NO2 (Lavonda)

  38. I found it reasonably exhausting since I didn’t know
    what I used to be doing.

    My webpage stud earrings sterling silver (

  39. Very soon this site will be famous amid all blogging
    and site-building users, due to it’s pleasant content

    Look at my web site How to get a real estate license in GA, Isaac,

  40. Good job.

    Look at my webpage – tsohost dns servers (Rosetta)

  41. Call your uncle forward of time to debate the difficulty,
    ” she suggests.

    My page web hosting panel (Emmett)

  42. Thanks for sharing.

    Feel free to visit my web blog – web hosting unlimited domains (Kristine)

  43. Wish to have a professional and aim-oriented web site?

    Also visit my blog :: web hosting iceland (Cynthia)

  44. We don’t supply a transfer service to maneuver your website
    from another provider. However, we do offer plenty
    of data on our Buyer Support pages that should provide help to with your switch.

    My page – tsohost wordpress install in path –

  45. You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I in finding
    this matter to be really something that I feel I would never understand.
    It seems too complicated and extremely huge for me. I
    am taking a look forward to your next put up, I will attempt to get the grasp of it!

    My weblog does patriot power greens work?

  46. While WordPress is completely free, you might rarely see
    ads served on your page. Also, there are a few restrictions which can be
    tagged along with WordPress.

    Feel free to surf to my weblog – web hosting quora (Helena)

  47. This incident started the diamond buying and selling trade for India.

    My blog; leather and silver bracelets – Preston

  48. A dependable and fast assist service is significant for your personal business progress just like the steadiness and reliability you want in your own website.

    In enterprise, reliability is mirrored by means of word-of-mouth as one of the effective promotional activities.

    my homepage … web hosting jaipur [Janell]

  49. Silver jewelry can actually make an unimaginable addition to this summer’s key trends, the pliability of
    silver makes it attainable for the effective use of brilliantly coloured semi-treasured stones and shimmering crystals
    to supply pieces which is able to really compliment summer trends.
    Silver bangles will complement the 70s glam trend while Swarovski crystals will
    really add to the brilliant vibrant items that you will find in many shops this summer.

    Review my homepage – how to macrame a bracelet (

  50. For anyone who wishes to have interaction in doing business on the Internet, step one ought to always be to find out which hosting company will host the businesses website.

    It may be straightforward to find out the bottom price, as well as discovering testimonials
    from clients about their experience with a respective internet
    hosting supplier. What won’t be as straightforward for the typical
    person to find out is whether the necessity UNIX hosting or Windows
    internet hosting.

    Here is my site – web hosting how to (Juli)

  51. great information.i too wish i had discovered this text once i first
    obtained began, it might’ve save me some headaches.

    my web site: web hosting hub complaints

  52. I am regular visitor, how are you everybody? This paragraph
    posted at this site is genuinely nice.

    Have a look at my weblog … patriot power greens review (Lonny)

  53. Store gold vermeil in an airtight container or a lined jewellery field, and
    by no means swim in a pool or take a bathe bathe while wearing it.

    My web blog :: Danon Jewellery Sale (Lesley)

  54. The Olympics theme suits effectively into the physical training curriculum at any grade degree.
    The kids participate in actions that simulate actual events in both
    the Summer or Winter Olympics.

    My homepage :: web hosting linux vs windows (Kate)

  55. Concerning scaling, their system is built for this however chances are you’ll
    wish to contact them for clarification regarding bursts.

    Here is my homepage: web hosting queensland

  56. Month-to-month bandwidth is the amount of data switch allowed for guests to view and use your web site.

    my website :: web hosting deals 2015 (Liam)

  57. Kundan jewelry which has edges that give off a discolored appearance
    is a sign the gold used in making the piece of jewellery is gold plated.

    Feel free to visit my website: pearl heart bracelet – Arturo

  58. In case you hold your silver jewellery clean and free from
    tarnish you’ll not get this.

    my blog post; Danon Jewellery Stockist –

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.