Oct 122007

One warm Sunday afternoon a few years back, I went with my scout group on a march against the Iraq war shortly after our weekly meeting. Dressed in our scout uniforms, we joined hundreds of protesters waving banners and flags, blowing whistles, and chanting anti-war slogans to the beat of drums. While enjoying the carnival-like atmosphere, I watched a photographer scouring the crowd with a large camera in his hand. Walking past one row of protesters after another, he suddenly stopped near us and aimed his lens. His target, mind you, was not the uniformed scouts with their sweet, colourful homemade placards, but two figures nearby, swathed in black from head to toe, with only their eyes showing, their foreheads covered with headbands which read “jihad now”.

Of all the hundreds present on the scene, it was the two sinister-looking figures that attracted the photographer’s lens. And this small incident is neither unique nor isolated. In reality, it captures the approach that large sections of the media in this country and others take on Muslim-related issues. The vast Muslim world, stretching over 12 million square miles, and its 1.5 billion people, are reduced to shouting mobs, battered wives, caged daughters and froth-mouthed clerics threatening the west with death and destruction. The images are often so disturbing, terrifying and nauseating that if I did not know enough of the subject and its complexities to enable me to question the messages conveyed, I would have disowned Islam and Muslims long ago and wanted to have nothing to do with either.

Some might argue that the media does not create these blood-curdling, stomach-churning images, but merely reports what is already in existence. Things, however, are not so straightforward. For the camera is neither neutral and innocent, nor objective and impartial. It is subject to a set of pre-defined choices and calculations that decide what we see and do not see, know and do not know, and how we see and know it. The media is not a mirror reflecting what is out there. Its role is not simple, passive transmission, but active creation, shaping and manufacturing, through a lengthy process of selection, filtering, interpretation and editing. The hidden arms that hold the reins of our media – the giant news corporations and their masters – we should remember, are not benign charities driven by the love of humanity.

Of the 57 countries in the vast geographic and cultural expanse known as the Muslim world, some are rich, others poor, some royal others republican, some conservative, others “progressive”, some stable, others less so, some where women preside over the state, others that deny them the right to vote, some where they head colleges, universities and research institutions, others where they cannot even go to primary school, some that oppress in the name of religion, others that do so in the name of secularism, some that ban the Islamic veil by force, others which impose it by force …

But this strikingly varied mosaic is absent from mainstream coverage of the subject. What we are left with is a mass of uniform deficiency, chaos, stagnation, violence and fanaticism. The Muslim world turns into a silent object that does not speak, but is spoken for, an anonymous background against which stands the reporter dispatched from the metropolis. S/he is the agent of understanding, the one who deciphers this strange entity’s mysterious codes and uncovers its secrets for us; the one who gives it meaning, truth and order.

But nowhere is the will to superficiality and reductionism more evident than in reports of conflicts in the Middle East. Viewers are given a few minutes during which they watch and hear descriptions of wreckage, mayhem, smoke, burnt cars, scorched bodies, severed limbs and blood. With no attempt to explain the underlying causes and histories of the crises in question, the reports merely compound existing misunderstanding. The confusion is such that roles are often reversed, with the victim mistaken for the oppressor.

This is confirmed by a number of studies, such as that conducted by Greg Philo and Mike Berry of the Glasgow University Group, who monitored hours of BBC and ITV coverage of the 2002 Palestinian Intifada, examined 200 news programmes, and interviewed over 800 people about their perceptions of the conflict. The researchers encountered an alarming level of ignorance and confusion among the viewers, of whom only 9% knew that the “occupied territories” were occupied by Israel, with the majority believing that the Palestinians were the occupiers.

This is hardly surprising given the unbalanced coverage, and its tendency to obscure the central truths in the conflict: It does not tell us that over 418 Palestinian villages were destroyed in 1948, that their inhabitants were expelled in their hundreds of thousands, that Israel was largely established by force on 78% of historic Palestine, that since 1967 it has illegally occupied and imposed various forms of military rule on the remaining 22%, or that the majority of Palestinians – over 8 million – live as refugees today.

Reports of the Iraq war do not fare better. The viewer is given the impression that the country’s ills are rooted in its people’s bloodthirstiness and love of self-mutilation, with one sect and ethnicity vying for the other’s destruction. The Americans emerge as benign mediators whose role consists in imposing order and preventing the different groups from exterminating each other.

The causes of the ongoing bloodletting are increasingly being brushed under the carpet, viz the 150,000 strong army deployed to invade a country hundreds of miles away, the destruction of its infrastructure, systematic demolition of its national collective memory, desecration of its cultural heritage, erection of an ethnic and sectarian based political system, dissolution of its army in the name of “de-baathisation”, and arming of one faction against the other, first the Kurdish Peshmarga, then the Shia militias in the name of “confronting the Sunni triangle”, and now al-Anbar’s Sunni tribes under the pretext of combating al-Qaida. Having torn Iraq’s social fabric apart, the Americans today speak of its division into three states under the banner of federalism.

What the media reports do not tell us is that Iraqis suffer today not because they are Arabs, Muslims, brown-skinned, or followers of an “inherently violent” religious culture, but because they are the victims of a heartless power game that saw them as little more than insects, worthless creatures to trample on without bothering to count the dead.

Imagine if some ruler decided to invade the British Isles under the pretext of changing its dated royal system headed by a monarch dismissed as a remnant of medieval feudalism incompatible with “our modern republican values”. Imagine if he moved his armies and war fleets to occupy the country, established his “green zone” in Westminster and set up a political order divided between the English, Scots, Welsh and Irish; Protestants, Catholics, Jews and other religious minorities. Would Britain fare better than Iraq? Would it be saved by its “great democratic values” and sublime “religion of love”?

The trouble is that our irresponsible media is not deforming our conception of an alien religion, faraway peoples, or distant conflicts and crises. In a world of overlapping borders of politics, culture and identity, it is playing recklessly with the tissue of our societies, and erecting high walls of ignorance, fear, and hatred in our midst.


First Published in The Guardian, Friday 12 October 2007

Warning: count(): Parameter must be an array or an object that implements Countable in /home/soumayag/public_html/wp-includes/class-wp-comment-query.php on line 399

  27 Responses to “Reporting Islam”

  1. Hello everyone, it’s my first go to see at this web site, and piece of writing is actually fruitful for me, keep up posting these content.

  2. They can review your encounter cleaning regime that is everyday and/or subscribe a particular medicine.

    Stop by my web blog – best face wash for acne prone skin uk (Kate)

  3. Pests and insects could cause harm to your home and your household’s health, the longer you allow them grow the
    even more they will grow.

    My webpage – bend oregon exterminator – Eve

  4. Controlling Ants: Like all your pals make sure you can get
    rid of a couple of Columbia MD ants Off to the
    store and you get a container of insect repellent you are visiting do.
    a few of your personal Columbia MD bend oregon pest control (Stepanie) control.

  5. Brand name mentions, or pertinent details that the source website is discussing your brand or
    web site, will certainly factor into your Search Engine Optimization ranking efforts.

    My blog … local seo services (Harriet)

  6. Our Bed bend oregon pest control (Elke) specialist
    is licensed, certified as well as is extremely experience; who’ll
    carry out residual spraying on your bed insect plagued
    harbourage locations as well as potential habitats to
    get rid of your bed bug infestation with prompt results.

  7. Prior to we get involved in the 5 on-page professional seo consultant (Leslee) techniques you can make
    use of to offer your website that rank boost, first make certain you have these fundamentals applied on your websites already:.

  8. Instead of dallas seo training being of its own distinct discipline, it will certainly be much more frequently used as a foundational part that is impacted by (and influences) the other
    elements of advertising (social networks and material).

  9. Insects that you do not want to damage and also you are most likely to see in the garden are
    ladybird beetles (ladybugs), eco-friendly lace wings, pirate insects, assassin pest and also soldier
    beetles Much less typical are the hoping mantids.

    my blog post – exterminator bend oregon

  10. Some pest control firms have a department that does wildlife removal job, but generally with
    an entirely separate staff from its insect control

    my webpage exterminator bend oregon

  11. Finally, all I could say is research study your dicision to
    obtain an insect solution by asking family and
    friends, one of them are most likely to have a pest control bend oregon (Kristina)
    service that they are happy with.

  12. Bee and wasp control sets you back $95 for one nest or $195 for entire residence prevention.

    Feel free to surf to my web site: exterminator bend oregon

  13. We merely contacted Modern Insect Solutions as well as they visited within a
    day to retreat our problem locations.

    Here is my homepage – pest control bend or [Otilia]

  14. The writer of the above item has an intriguing view of pests
    however I would certainly never pay 600 bucks to clear my life of ants.

    Have a look at my site … bend oregon exterminator

  15. The element and scrolling of the inside of the watch face and back accompanied with its concave shape will not be suitable for engraving.

  16. Android Put on gadgets have first rate set of well being apps,
    together with the continually-improved Google Fit , and most manufacturers embody their very own specialised apps too.

  17. Test the smartwatch comparability to see what we appreciated and did not like about each

  18. In some drones accessible you’ll learn that
    the utmost journey interval after one full-charge is typically 25 minutes.

  19. Consumer testimonies and views are not unhelpful when looking for
    an acne treatment that works.

    my web blog best spot acne treatment drugstore [Terrence]

  20. That mentioned, not all brands are benefiting
    from this channel in the most worthwhile means, however – fairly than give attention to the detrimental – Luxury
    Society has joined forces with full service digital agency Digital Luxury Group to identify and
    rank these luxurious watch and jewellery manufacturers doing it right.

  21. She as well as various other hygienics officials state reduced gas rates cannot be identified as the single reason for the increased spread of bed insects, but the lower fuel costs might be among numerous aspects.

    my website – bend oregon exterminator (Carmel)

  22. The most effective spot treatment of acne in the less traditional category, you’ll notice about Tree Oil.

    Also visit my web page: best face wash for acne
    prone skin 2015 (Gemma)

  23. I adore the product!!! Her excellent nice new nike shoes http://www.aliexpress.com/store/group/Hiking-Shoes/1950023_506538526.html go perfectly.

  24. You have made some really good points there. I checked on the web to
    learn more about the issue and found most people will go along with
    your views on this website.

  25. Thank you, I’ve just been searching for information about this subject for a while and yours is the greatest I have found out so far. However, what in regards to the conclusion? Are you sure in regards to the source?|

  26. If you are desperate for treating acne, to begin with the house treatments feel liberated to miss ahead!

    Also visit my web-site: acne cream benzoyl peroxide 5 (Jefferson)

  27. gOF4JR Just wanted to say thanks for posting this!

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.