Oct 302015



If I got a penny for every time I was told that religion is the cause of all trouble, I’d be a rich woman by now. If only we had John Lennon’s religionless world, there would be no war, or conflict and everyone would love their neighbour. If only the theologians, clergymen, mullahs and priests could get on, the world’s problems would be resolved at a stroke.

No doubt, religion does play a part in many of the crises and conflicts raging around us. But more often than not, these problems take on a religious name and speak through the medium of religion, while having their roots in socio-political factors.

Examples are found in the Northern Ireland dispute as in the Middle East conflict. Though those at loggerheads happen to belong to divergent confessional communities, Catholics and Protestants, Jews and Muslims/Christians, they did not come to blows because of their religious affiliations. Their grievances are fundamentally political, even if they hide themselves in the guise of religion and communicate in its language.

Religion is often the mirror that reflects worldly tensions. To say that religion is divisive is to attempt no analysis of the problems at hand. It is to stop at the surface making no effort to dig deeper for the underlying problems seething underneath.

Take the orgy of sectarian bloodshed that has been raging in Iraq for over a decade, for instance. Sunnis and Shia have been killing each other by the tens on a daily basis. Do not venture into a Sunni dominated area if your name happens to be Hassan, and you have more chance of ending up with a slit throat on some street corner if you suddenly lost your way and found yourself in Sadr city and you were called Omar.

But let us not stop there, let us ask the difficult questions others would rather we left undisturbed. Why do Iraq’s Sunni and Shia kill each other today when they didn’t years ago? Why were they able to coexist before, but find that impossible to do today? Every Iraqi tribe and family numbers both Sunni and Shia. They intermingled, intermarried, lived not only side by side but under the same roof, often sharing the same bed. This was the case even under Saddam’s despotic rule. Then and before, for centuries Iraq was one of the world’s most diverse places, a veritable mosaic of religions, ethnicities, sects and denominations, Muslims, Christians, Sabians, Yazidis, Sunni, Shia, Kurds, Turkmen all peacefully shared the same space.

This was Iraq before. It isn’t Iraq today, since the American/British invasion and Bremer’s transitional authority, which destroyed Iraq’s political order, substituting it for one grounded in sectarianism and ethnic factionalism. National identity was broken asunder, the common torn apart, only narrow group affiliations remained. In the chaos that followed, every splinter group wanted to seize all, leaving the rest with nothing. Forming the security and police forces in the new Iraq along sectarian lines poured oil over fire, equipping one faction with the tools it would later use in its quest to exterminate its rivals.

Shiism and Sunnism are not to blame. Bush, Blair and Bremer are.

Neither are Judaism, Christianity, or Islam responsible for the Middle East conflict. Palestinians and Israelis invoke religious symbols and references in their rationalisation of the dispute, in a space laden with sacred meanings for both sides. But the truth is that this is not a conflict over a mosque, church, or temple, though it has come to be symbolised by such monuments. Primarily, and above all, it is over land, dispossession, settlement, occupation and will to liberation. The relationship is more between occupier and occupied than between Jew and Muslim/Christian. More than the Quran or the Old Testament, it is the Balfour Declaration and the great powers’ strategies in the region that have spawned and dictated the course of this long and painful drama.

Many more examples could be cited for the superficiality of explanations of socio-political movements and phenomena in exclusively religious terms, from the Reformation in 16th century Europe, to Islamic radicalism in the 21st. Religion is neither the root of all virtue, nor the cause of all evil. Good conditions spawn good religion, bad conditions bad religion. The evils of reality have a habit of metamorphosing into evil religion. It is the chaotic war-torn and crisis ridden Middle East today that fosters and nourishes the extreme violent ideology of al-Qaeda and ISIS.

Humans and societies are not blank pages, but the carriers of a profound cultural, symbolic, and historic heritage, through which they communicate and make sense of reality. This imbedded repository of values, images and references, is inevitably invoked in peace as in war, and more so in war and times of turmoil. Amidst tension, cultural, religious, and national identities are awakened, activated, and intensified.

This is not to say, as Marx had done, that religion is a superfluous illusion. It is an integral part of the collective memory and consciousness of groups and individuals. Through it they ascribe meaning to their experiences and justification to their actions. It functions silently unnoticed amidst stability and calm and becomes more vocal, more visible and sometimes more explosive through crisis and turbulence. There is no inherently peaceful religion, and no inherently aggressive religion. Take Christianity, for instance, it inspired asceticism and otherworldliness, just as it ignited the flames of conflict and schism, in the 16th century, wars of religion as in the Crusades. There is no religion per se.

In short, we would do well to avoid peering at reality through the prism of ideas and doctrines. Humans, you see, walk on their feet, not their heads.


Warning: count(): Parameter must be an array or an object that implements Countable in /home/soumayag/public_html/wp-includes/class-wp-comment-query.php on line 399

  19 Responses to “Religion is not to blame”

  1. Please let me know if you’re looking for a author for your site.
    You have some really good articles and I think I would be a good asset.
    If you ever want to take some of the load off, I’d
    really like to write some articles for your blog in exchange for a link back to mine.
    Please send me an e-mail if interested. Regards!

  2. This is a topic which is close to my heart… Best wishes! Where are your contact details though?|

  3. I finally discovered something that helped my acne and it’s really all natural plant based materials.

    my web site – best drugstore acne spot treatment yahoo (Petra)

  4. Incredibly wonderful led self balancing board scooter bluetooth speaker http://www.aliexpress.com/store/group/10inch-Hover-Board/1950023_505404968.html for the winter! They retain me vogue and toasty!

  5. I blog often and I really appreciate your information. The article has really peaked my interest. I’m going to take a note of your website and keep checking for new information about once per week. I opted in for your RSS feed as well.|

  6. I prefer the AcneFree Original Formulation with 2% Benzoyl Peroxide as my standard BP
    spot-treatment product.

    Also visit my homepage :: acne products walgreens

  7. The Bearded Gent is an enjoyable, amusing, and also useful overview of face hair
    designs and the males that wear them.

    Here is my blog post; http://www.aapkafree.com

  8. % The human body is constantly under attack from bacteria, viruses and
    fungi that encourage an infection. Like many things in life, moderation and common sense are key.

    Here is my web blog hiit weight training routine (Marita)

  9. Attractive section of content. I just stumbled upon your blog
    and in accession capital to assert that I get actually
    enjoyed account your blog posts. Any way I
    will be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.

    Have a look at my web blog dr oz garcinia cambogia (storify.com)

  10. There will certainly be some of you that have actually never tried
    a beard before, conforming to the regimen of shaving every day.

    Feel free to visit my web page; arredoufficiomarca.com – Willis

  11. %It is not a matter of training for hours on end every day. You can shed fat from your belly and under your arms with rigorous but smart exercise. It is a matter of making every minute of your exercise as efficient as possible.

    Here is my website … hiit bodybuilding, http://n4g.com/,

  12. %The defining characteristic of human beings is our ability to freely communicate and share knowledge with one another.

    Here is my site fat loss and weight training (http://www.nature.com)

  13. Make sure to also review the Murdock Barbers’ professional 3-step pet grooming overview, assured to help treat enormous levels of irritability.

    Feel free to visit my page – veteranlan.com

  14. Prevent beard oils consisting of grapeseed as well as coconut oils as the previous could effortlessly
    go bad as well as some people have a chain reaction to the last creating their beard to smell musty.

    my site … trvlunion.ru (Loretta)

  15. Before we start, I ought to point out that beard growth depends on numerous organic elements.

    Visit my blog – mirun.me (Anglea)

  16. %Listen to the jargons of the runners about the Interval Exercise Method and the Fatekele Training Method and they are enough to cast this game for golf. Exercise may be transformed into a complicated thing and therefore makes one step back.

    Here is my page; interval training programme [vimeo.com]

  17. %High-Intensity Interval Training, or HIIT, is one of the best methods for muscle retention and fat loss. Studies have shown that long endurance activities such as aerobics cause the breakdown of muscle tissue, which is why HIIT should be emphasized.

    Feel free to surf to my blog; hiit interval training (http://www.dipity.com)

  18. %Here, the training is given by best and highly qualified instructors most of them being professional body builders.

    Look into my blog; weight training and fat loss

  19. If you wish to utilize styling items, I ‘d suggest using a beard
    balm while your beard is still moist, then coiffure.

    my web page – http://www.energydynamicsafrica.com

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.